Analyzing Quine’s Theory of the Indeterminacy of Translation

W.V.O Quine has favored contextual translation in his book “Word and Object” to the extent that it renders the importance of accuracy in translation almost meaningless. According to Quine’s viewpoint, while translating a manual from any language into English, all alternative translations of the same manual would be correct as long as they fit the speech patterns of the native speakers of that language. The readers might prefer one translation over the other but it has nothing to do with the prowess or skill of the translator. This preference is personal according to Quine, depending on the words/phrases striking the fancy of a reader or because the interpretation is close to one’s own view of the world.

Quine explains his theory as follows:

Two translators might develop independent manuals of translation, both of them compatible with all speech behavior, and yet one manual would offer translations that the other translator would reject. My position was that either manual could be useful, but as to which was right and which  wrong, there was no fact of the matter.”

If we accept Quine’s theory, we should not be judging or comparing the work done by two different translation services or translators. Language and its translation  is all about interpretation and Quine’s theory is proved useful by the fact that literal translation fails to convey any meaning. A good translation is always the closest natural equivalent  of the original document. CNE strives to provide the readers with the exact meaning of the document as was intended in the source language, keeping the expression natural for the native speakers, again for the purpose of comprehension.

In the present world, due to the growing need of intercultural communication  and the world becoming a global market, more translators are required. Translation service companies recruit  German translators, French translators, Italian translators, Chinese and Korean translators, Arabic translators, Portuguese translators, Polish and Spanish translators. If we were to believe the theory of Quine, which I completely agree with, all translators are able and skilled. As long as the translator has a command on the target language,  the interpretations could vary. There is no such thing as a good translator and a bad translator. This is a wrong perception which the translation service companies should not support. All translators are competent and comparisons between the translated manuals are pointless.

Quine gives his theory the name of “Indeterminacy of Translation” whereby translation always requires some background information which might not be available in the original text which is to be translated. Here the translator has to work through some assumptions according to his own beliefs and experiences which might vary from person to person. This results in different interpretations by different translators. According to Quine, only observation sentences could be translated accurately whereas there is little room for variation in the translation of standing sentences. Quine thinks that there is a room for indeterminacy in observation sentences even, meaning there are different ways to report the same observation.

This demonstrates that translation at times is indeterminate. But not all linguists tend to agree with Quine. It only clarifies the point that there is no such thing as a perfect or imperfect translation. Translation is an arduous job, and there could be more than one possible translation of the same document.

Selecting A Quality Language Translation Provider

About Us

THE MARKETING ANALYSTS is a leading language translation company that provides translations and interpretations between English and more than 150 other languages.  For your global translation needs, you can count on THE MARKETING ANALYSTS to provide the highest quality English, Spanish, German, French, Italian, Arabic, Hindi, Portuguese, Chinese Mandarin, Japanese, Korean, and Thai language translation service.  We are also a leading provider of specialized translations for medical, engineering, legal, electronics, hospitality/menu and other technical fields.  Visit our website today or call us today (888-600-8830 or 941-258-1462) for a free quotation.

Evaluating Translation Services

With the market full of translation companies, selecting an accurate and reliable translation company can be extremely challenging.  Here is a list of several factors to evaluate when selecting a translation service.

History and Experience

Consider the number of years that the translation has been in business.  Generally, companies with greater tenure are most likely to provide quality work and have high quality, knowledgeable translation specialists in your field.  THE MARKETING ANALYSTS has 20-years of experience in the translation service industry.  During this time, we have successfully serviced the needs of individuals, corporations and government agencies that have required medical, legal, financial, technical and other fields that require translators with specialized training, education and expertise.

Qualifications

How does a translation company screen potential translators?  Does the translation service company have a formal recruitment and selection process in place in order to guarantee the highest quality service?     THE MARKETING ANALYSTS requires that each candidate for a translation position have a minimum of ten years of verifiable professional translation experience.  We also perform thorough reference checks that relate to past translation projects.  Our educational requirements insist on native level language proficiency combined with an advanced degree or certification in their specialized subject field.

On-Time Service and Project Management

Your project has deadlines and you need peace of mind that your project will be completed on time.  On average, our translators complete 2,000 words per day.  However, we also offer rush service in case your project has very short deadlines.  While we do charge extra for rush service, we might be able to meet your tight deadline.  Please call us and we will tell you for sure.

Honest & Knowledgeable Customer Service

Time is money and you cannot spare either on novice professional service providers.  When you work with THE MARKETING ANALYSTS, you can expect quick and honest answers to your questions. We are interested in your long-term business and work hard to earn your respect and positive word of mouth referrals. Therefore, we expect you to ask questions and you can expect our utmost attention.

Price

Different translation companies have different pricing structures.  Most companies will charge per word.  However, rates may differ based on the specific language and localization, education and expertise of the translator, and additional services like desktop publishing and express services.    It is important to realize that if a price seems too low, then it probably is.

THE MARKETING ANALYSTS is a U.S. based company that serves clients throughout the world.  With two decades of success, THE MARKETING ANALYSTS remains true to the values that fuel its success today: accurate, fast, friendly, and honest service.   Our clients can still count on receiving this exceptional service.  As a leading translation services company, we are committed to helping you achieve your communication goals.

Read More About Our Translation Service

Read More About Our Translation Services:

Arabic Translation, Chinese Translation, English Translation, French Translation, German Translation, Hindi Translation, Italian Translation, Japanese Translation, Korean Translation, Polish Translation, Portuguese Translation, Russian Translation, Spanish Translation, Turkish Translation, Vietnamese Translation

Providing Local Service in the Following Communities:

Anchorage • Chicago • South Bend • Cincinnati • Cleveland • Columbus • Dallas • Fort Worth • Indianapolis • Kansas-City • Louisville • Oklahoma City • Omaha • Saint Louis • Baltimore • Boston • Jacksonville • Miami • New York • Philadelphia • Raleigh • Tampa • Washington D.C. • Denver • Las Vegas • Los Angeles • Mesa • Portland • Sacramento • San Diego • San Francisco • San Jose • Seattle • Atlanta • Austin • Birmingham • El Paso • Houston • Nashville • Phoenix • San Antonio

Medical Translation Service that You Can Trust-Certified Medical Translators

Medical Translation Service From THE MARKETING ANALYSTS

Medical Translation Service From THE MARKETING ANALYSTS

For the past 20-years, THE MARKETING ANALYSTS has provided medical translation service for the health professions.  From our local offices in Dallas, Texas and Fort Myers, Florida, we offer local service to leading hospitals throughout the US.  The success of our company is based on strong ethics and quality assurance measures that leave no room for error.

With lives at risk, it’s critically important that your medical translation firm provide complete accuracy, professionalism and on-time service.  At THE MARKETING ANALYSTS, we feel a moral obligation to provide error free medical translations.

The translation of medical documents is a highly specialized field. It requires professional knowledge, uncompromised levels of accuracy and timely delivery.  Our US staff includes licensed medical professionals, hospital administration professionals, project managers and over 180 translation specialists that work together to achieve the highest translation quality and translation service.

Documents we translate:
Clinical Studies, Medical Records, EOBs, Registration documents, Hospital Websites, Product information leaflets, Patient Education Brochures, Protocols, Reports, Safety and Infection Control documents, Healthcare legal documents, Signage and more.

Going Beyond Your Expectations.

Medical translation is a highly skilled field that requires specialized training.  It is not enough to simply be competent in a foreign language.  Our criterion for selecting medical translators is rigorous and requires industry-specialist knowledge and five consecutive years of translation experience.

In addition to providing medical record translation service, we also provide translations for medical devices that include cardio device translation, orthopedic device translation, and ophthalmology translation.

Providing Translations in over 180 Languages
THE MARKETING ANALYSTS is your one stop for language translation and interpretation services.  While we provide translations in over 180 languages, some of our most common include the following: We provide Language Translation Service covering a broad range of multilingual projects.  Our most common language translations include: Arabic Translation, Chinese Translation, English Translation, French Translation, German Translation, Hindi Translation, Italian Translation, Japanese Translation, Korean Translation, Polish Translation, Portuguese Translation, Russian Translation, Spanish Translation, Turkish Translation, and Vietnamese Translation.

Dallas, Texas • Fort Myers, Florida • Sofia, Bulgaria • Cologne, Germany • Moscow, Russia

US TOLL FREE: 866-371-4863
INTL:
239-243-0767
FAX: 480-393-5183
Email: info@themarketinganalysts.com

Selecting the Right Translator for Oil, Gas, Drilling, Mining & Refining Language Translation

Selecting an accurate Oil, Gas, Drilling, Refining or Mining Translation Specialist is critical to companies serving the energy industry.  As new technologies emerge and energy exploration expands outside the Middle East and Russia, the ability to communicate in multiple languages has become increasingly important.  For these reasons, THE MARKETING ANALYSTS specialize in oil translation, gas translation, drilling translation, and mining translation services.  Our competencies include the technical know-how to assemble engineering reports, operation manuals and scientific studies in over 180 languages that include Arabic Translation, Chinese Translation, English Translation, French Translation, German Translation, Hindi Translation, Italian Translation, Japanese Translation, Korean Translation, Polish Translation, Portuguese Translation, Russian Translation, Spanish Translation, Turkish Translation, and Vietnamese Translation.

When it comes to translation, we get it right the first time by employing experienced professionals who are native to the target language.   Once your translation is complete, all translated documents are proofread, ready to print and typeset when needed.  Our proven project management methods ensure on-time delivery and complete accuracy.

Free Quote

Having completed dozens of translation projects for oil and gas companies throughout the world, we are ready to take on your project and exceed your expectations.  Please use our form to receive a free no obligation report.

Dallas, Texas • Fort Myers, Florida • Sofia, Bulgaria • Cologne, Germany • Moscow, Russia

US TOLL FREE: 866-371-4863
INTL:
239-243-0767
FAX: 480-393-5183
Email: info@themarketinganalysts.com